1) Chicago White Sox
What to like: The White Sox have a very potent lineup that got even better with the addition of slugger Adam Dunn, who is always a threat to hit one out as long as he can make contact. They have a pair of young stars in the middle infield in 2B Gordon Beckham and SS Alexi Ramirez, each of whom have showed promise early in their careers and should continue to develop nicely. OF Alex Rios appears to have put a disastrous 2009 season split between Toronto and Chicago behind him.
What not to like: The pitching staff is full of question marks and could be the club’s undoing if those questions go unanswered. Staff ace Mark Beuhrle posted a pedestrian 4.28 ERA last season, and the rest of the rotation has shown flashes of both brilliance and incompetence. The bullpen has lost a couple of quality arms in Bobby Jenks and J.J. Putz , and the closer role is somewhat up in the air.
Outlook: If the pitching staff can keep the White Sox close, the offense should be able to slug its way to a lot of runs and a division title.
Key Player: Buehrle. The four time All-Star and two time Gold Glove winner has had an interesting career. His season ERA has been below 3.50 only twice in his 11 year career, and has recorded double-digit losses seven times, yet he is still considered one of the game’s best, partly due to his durability, and partly due to penchant for dramatically brilliant play: he’s thrown a no-hitter and a perfect game, set the Major League record with 45 straight batters retired and made one of baseball’s most memorable plays on Opening Day last year. He remains the White Sox most consistent pitcher, for better or for worse, and he is the key to their division title run.
X-factor: RHP Jake Peavy. The former Cy Young winner disappointed in his first full season with the White Sox, posting a 7-6 record with an ERA of 4.63 while starting just 17 games in an injury plagued year. He is still recovering from mid-season surgery that ended his season last year, and the earliest estimate for his return is late April. If he returns at anything resembling the level he was at when he was with the Padres, he can help solidify an otherwise iffy rotation.
Notable additions: Dunn
Notable subtractions: Jenks, Putz, OF Andruw Jones, DH Manny Ramirez
2) Minnesota Twins
What to like: The Twins have a pair of perennial MVP candidates anchoring the middle of their lineup with C Joe Mauer and 1B Justin Morneau. An unheralded starting rotation is loaded with solid talent, led by a pair of once-dead stars in Francisco Liriano and Carl Pavano. Closer Joe Nathan looks healthy after undergoing Tommy John surgery just before the start of last season.
What not to like: Morneau (.192 BA, no HR) and Nathan (11.30 ERA) both struggled in spring training, hinting that while they’re healthy and ready to play on Opening Day, they may not return to their pre-injury production levels. The Twins also lost their starting middle infield from last year, and replaced them with a couple of unknown quantities in Japanese import Tsuyoshi Nishioka and disappointing prospect Alexi Casilla.
Outlook: The Twins have won the division in back-to-back seasons, and they seem to be in the mix every year despite several worrisome off-seasons. It would not surprise me at all to see the Twins playing baseball in October yet again.
Key player: Mauer. The 2009 AL MVP saw his numbers dip somewhat in 2010, but he remained one of the game’s best hitters, even from a traditionally light-hitting position. The three-time batting champion probably isn’t as much of a threat to go deep as he was in 2009 (28 HR), but his health and continued production is tantamount to the Twins success, meaning a move to first base or DH is probably not far off.
X-factor: Nathan. The Twins title hopes took a huge hit late in spring training last year when it was announced that their All-Star closer would miss the entire season, and though they managed to capture the title without him, Nathan is still a very important piece of the Twins’ bullpen. He didn’t perform well in Spring Training, and the Twins hope he’ll return to form once the games start to count.
Notable additions: SS Nishioka
Notable subtractions: SS J.J. Hardy, 2B Orlando Hudson, LHP Brian Fuentes
3) Detroit Tigers
What to like: The middle of the Tigers lineup is filled with some of the game’s best hitters in 1B Miguel Cabrera, OF Magglio Ordonez and C/DH Victor Martinez. The starting rotation should be much improved after the team jettisoned drastically underperforming Dontrelle Willis and Jeremy Bonderman, as well as would-be perfect gamer Armando Gallaraga. The addition of RHP Joaquin Benoit from the Rays should bolster a shaky bullpen.
What not to like: Cabrera’s off-season problems (see below) are becoming a major issue. Despite improvements, there’s not a lot to love about the starting rotation. Benoit may not be enough to improve the league’s 4th worst bullpen last year.
Outlook: Any of the top three teams could win the Central if everything goes right for them. The Tigers, however, probably have too many ifs to come out on top in 2011.
Key player: Cabrera. The Tigers’ best hitter is a sure-fire Hall of Famer – if he can put the bottle down long enough to stay out of trouble. A DUI arrest in February was his second very public incident with substance abuse, and while his off-the-field problems have yet to affect his on-field performance, another major incident could net a stiff penalty from the league office. He is the Tigers’ most important player, and they need him to stay on the field.
X-factor: RHP Max Scherzer. The Arizona Diamondbacks import had a disastrous start to his 2010 season, but returned from a demotion to AAA to recover and have a decent season. He has shown the ability to be a very serviceable middle of the rotation for a contender, and his progression will be key to the success of the rotation.
Notable additions: Benoit, Martinez, RHP Brad Penny
Notable subtractions: Bonderman, Willis, Gallaraga, OH Johnny Damon
4) Kansas City Royals
What to like: The farm system is the best in baseball, and so the 2013 theoretical Royals look like a bona fide World Series contender. For now, that’s about all the Royals have going for them until the prospects start to arrive.
What not to like: The big league team is fraught with has-beens and busts. OF Alex Gordon, once the future of the Royals franchise, hasn’t reached .250 or 10 home runs since 2008, and is likely to be replaced when the new future of the franchise arrives. The rest of the outfield is populated with prospect-turned-bust castoffs from the Yankees (Melky Cabrera) and Braves (Jeff Francoeur).
Outlook: It’s going to take at least one, maybe two or three years for the Royals to be a contender, but they appear to be on the edge of breaking out. That is, as long as most of their highly touted prospects turn out. For now, the veteran placeholders will team up with the first of the young talent to arrive at the big league level, and they should be able to spring past the Indians and get out of the AL Central cellar.
Key player: Billy Butler, DH. Butler is Kansas City’s best offensive weapon for the time being. He’s set career highs in batting average, OBP and OPS last season, and at 24-years-old, he’s one of the only current Royals not likely to be replaced when the prospects start to arrive.
X-factor: The outfield. All three starters in the outfield are one-time big name prospects who have disappointed mightily at the big league level. Their production, or lack thereof, in 2011 will go a long way in determining the success of this year’s club.
Notable additions: OF Melky Cabrera, OF Lorenzo Cain, SS Alcides Escobar, LHP Jeff Francis
Notable subtractions: RHP Zach Grienke, OF David DeJesus, SS Yuniesky Betancourt
5) Cleveland Indians
What to like: The last holdovers from the 2007 ALCS run, OF Grady Sizemore and RHP Fausto Carmona, are still here to lead the offense and pitching staff, respectively. OF Shin-Soo Choo, a star in the making, avoided mandatory military service in his native South Korea when the national team won gold at the 2009 Asian Games. Highly anticipated catching prospect Carlos Santana appears to be fully recovered from a 2010 season-ending knee injury.
What not to like: With the fire sale the Indians have been running since that ALCS run, it’s unlikely that more than one of the three players mentioned above will be stuck in Cleveland past the All-Star break. Sizemore will start the season on the DL, and isn’t likely to ever regain his perennial All-Star form. Several of the prospects the Indians received in return for former stars like C.C. Sabathia, Cliff Lee and Victor Martinez have failed to pan out.
Outlook: It’s going to be another long summer for Cleveland sports fans; not to be confused with its long falls (the Browns) or winters (the Cavs). Its hard to believe a team that was one win away from the World Series in 2007 has fallen so far so fast.
Key player: Choo. The South Korean gold medal at the 2009 Asian Games is the best thing to happen to Cleveland since the Cavs drafted LeBron. He’s hit .300 with 20 HR and 20 SB in each of the last two seasons, and is the centerpiece of an otherwise stagnant offense.
X-factor: 1B Matt LaPorta. Once one of the most highly anticipated prospects in baseball, LaPorta has been a huge disappointment since coming over from the Brewers in the Sabathia deal. He’s hit .232 with 19 home runs in 162 games over parts of two seasons. The Indians still have hope that he can be the hitter they anticipated him being, but it seems unlikely at this point.
Notable additions: 2B Orlando Cabrera
Notable subtractions: None